Kastor’s cutlery empire: Germania Cutlery Works and Rather & Co?

Arie Leib

Premium Mitglied
Beiträge
233
Good evening, gentlemen.
Tonight I'd like to share my catch with you and ask your opinions.
So, the first find:
Germania Cutlery Works. This brand was created by Nathan Kastor in 1896 and existed until his death in 1938. More about the famous Kastor family later. The blades work perfectly, with a half-stop and a rich click when opening and closing. The body is nickel-silver, the interior is brass. No skimping on materials. The interior is yellow celluloid. The hallmark and materials indicate a period from the 1920s and 1930s. Germania Cutlery Works from Solingen is one of dozens of brands owned by the Kastors. They were the largest importer of cutlery from Europe to the United States, operating dozens of factories in Germany, France, England, and Bohemia. A little bit of history, shared by Codger from the American Knife Forum: “
In the 1840's, German immigrants came over and started businesses in the major U.S. cities. Many of them specialized in dry-goods... hardware... imported through firms in New York and distributed from there as manufacturing was not advancing with products and volumes to keep up with the demands of the growing nation. Natchez and Vicksburg were the locations of two such hardware firms, H. Bodenheim and Meyers and Kastor. After the war circa 1865-1866, these men moved to New York City to become importers themselves, forming Bodenheim, Meyers and Kastor.

On the eve of the Franco-Prussian war, Kastor's nephew immigrated and went to work in his Uncle's firm. Not long afterward, the principal partner, Henry Bodenheim died and the firm struggled for several years before closing. Aaron Kastor's nephew was Adolph Kastor (Koester). Adoph borrowed money from his uncle and started his own import business specializing in knives. His three brothers (Sigmund, August and Nathan) joined him in the venture and the firm became Adolph Kastor and Brothers. Still needing more knives than they could procure from England and Europe, they first leased and then bought Camillus Cutlery and imported German cutlers to work there. SO that is the Kastor-Camillus connection.

Oh yeah... Henry Bodenheim was the grandfather of The Baer brothers, Albert and "Uncle Henry" Baer. Thus Albert came to acquire a job with Camillus leading to his ownershiop of major shares of that firm before leaving to start his own cutlery just pre-WWII. He acquired the remaining shares from the Kastor heirs in 1963. So there is the Ulster-Schrade-Imperial connection to Camillus. And to the Kastors. Albert Baer's two daughters married into the Kauffman and Furgal families. Betsy and Margie were given the Camillus stocks and their husbands and children ran Camillus while the patriarch remained the behind the scenes business director giving advice, hiring key employees and sending them business to the point of using Camillus as an ancillary production line for Imperial Schrade. And the business relationship continued even after Henry's and Albert's deaths right up until Schrade closed in 2004 and Camillus closed in 2007. The history of this company is just too rich to allow it to fade into obscurity in my opinion. It isn't just the rote history of a business, but the interactions of many lives... the founders, the owners, the cutlers and other employees. It is a fascinating story of the evolution of the cutlery industry in America and Germany and how the principals adapted to the changing market, world events and events in their personal lives.”
This knife I have shown here represents the earlier days when the American nation was growing so fast that the very few domestic cutleries could not produce knives in quantiles to keep up with demand. "GERMANIA CUTL WORKS" was the name of the Kastors' German plant. Which also was an exporter of many European cutleries. This on top of selling everything their Camillus factory could turn out. This knife represents one small slice of that history.

IMG_7639.jpeg
IMG_7640.jpeg
IMG_7641.jpeg
IMG_7642.jpeg
IMG_7646.jpeg
IMG_7642.jpeg
IMG_7643.jpeg
IMG_7644.jpeg


The second knife from Rather & Co is a big mystery for all knife lovers. Knives from this brand are very rare, but everyone notes their excellent quality. I have a friend on the American knife forum who has several knives of this brand, bought in Texas 10 years ago. He still hasn't been able to find out anything about them. Hi, Ken. But let's take it from the beginning. The knife is of excellent quality, with carbon steel blades and the inscription in French "Acier superfine" on the blade. The logo features two scraped swords or epees and the brand name Rather & Co. Some examples are marked "Czechoslovakia," while others are stamped "Wadsworth Austria." All this only adds to the confusion. It is known that Wadsworth, a former British company, was acquired by the Kastor family and was a distributor of cutlery from Europe to the USA. So why the inscription in French? Regarding the Austria and Czechoslovakia hallmarks, it's more or less clear, since Bohemia (later Czechoslovakia) was part of the Austro-Hungarian Habsburg Empire until 1918. Dear experts, I ask you to help us unravel this mystery. After all, these stunning antique knives are worth it. Just look at the lovely Moustache comb! The scales are made of genuine mother-of-pearl. All the parts work perfectly, with an excellent click and half-stop. Poor Ken, the owner of several Rather & Co knives, has been puzzled since 2015. His friends on the American forum don't even know such a country as Czechoslovakia exists. I hope I'm not mistaken in associating the Rather & Co brand with the Kastor family. After all, many European knifemakers, including those from Bohemia, once worked for them. Ken and I look forward to your opinions and comments. Enjoy

IMG_7648.jpeg
IMG_7647.jpeg
IMG_7649.jpeg
IMG_7650.jpeg
IMG_7651.jpeg
IMG_7652.jpeg
IMG_7653.jpeg
IMG_7654.jpeg
IMG_7655.jpeg
IMG_7657.jpeg
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
Outstanding knives, and lots of great information! Thank you for that! In fact; until now I never thought of "Uncle Henry" being a real person ... :)
 
It is a fascinating story of the evolution of the cutlery industry in America and Germany and how the principals adapted to the changing market, world events and events in their personal lives.”
Well @Arie Leib and it’s an everlasting story of migration and immigration, maintained networking and mutual enrichment in their business.

Like the roots of the „Rather…“ knife, too. I will come to that back later.

Abu
 
My findings about WADSWORTH you already know. Probably from the same source of US-Forums.
Wadsworth; Eine Story aus USA-Solingen-Austria (https://messerforum.net/threads/wadsworth-eine-story-aus-usa-solingen-austria.145142/)

As you said, your knife is of very high quality! At first glance I would have definated Bohemia as country of origin. But….
Well known knives all seem to carry a stamp of origin, Like Austria/Czech. Which is missing on yours. Instead there is a french term on the blade. Rather was a trader, so why shouldn‘t your knife come from France? Just an idea…. The puzzle still ongoing.

Abu
 
My findings about WADSWORTH you already know. Probably from the same source of US-Forums.
Wadsworth; Eine Story aus USA-Solingen-Austria (https://messerforum.net/threads/wadsworth-eine-story-aus-usa-solingen-austria.145142/)

As you said, your knife is of very high quality! At first glance I would have definated Bohemia as country of origin. But….
Well known knives all seem to carry a stamp of origin, Like Austria/Czech. Which is missing on yours. Instead there is a french term on the blade. Rather was a trader, so why shouldn‘t your knife come from France? Just an idea…. The puzzle still ongoing.

Abu
I've been thinking about this, but there are knives with the Rather & Co. mark that have the same inscription engraved in French, "Acier Superfine," but also have the Czechoslovakian mark. Therefore, I'm increasingly inclined to believe that the country of origin is Bohemia. However, I haven't found the Rather & Co. brand among Czech manufacturers. However, we also know that the Kastors placed orders with factories in Germany, France, England, and Bohemia. And they had many registered brands. The name Rather & Co. sounds British. At one time, the Kastors bought Wostenholm, along with its trademarks (Wadsworth was one of them). So, it's possible this was contract manufacturing. For example, an English brand, but made in Bohemia.
Now, regarding the French inscription: A hundred years ago, the United States was developing rapidly, consumer demand was growing, and local production was insufficient to meet it. This was true for all industries, not just cutlery. Naturally, this gave a huge boost to imports. Enterprising European immigrants took advantage of this, leveraging connections in their countries of origin. At the time, European goods were in high demand and were a symbol of quality and prestige. This is clearly evident in movies about the mafia and the Prohibition era. They show the streets of New York and other major US cities. Advertisements hang on the streets: "Imported beer, clothing from Europe, European fabrics, haberdashery, jewelry, and so on." Products from France held a special place. A hundred years ago, as now, France is synonymous with the fashion industry, beauty, and luxury goods. So, a French inscription on a gentleman's knife could have added value and cost. It was a marketing ploy. But this is all conjecture; the answer can be found by obtaining a long list of brands owned and imported by the Kastors.
 
I would be pleased to find it’s origin in Bohemia, you know. So I checked catalogues with plenty of knives to find a similar pattern, in vain. Your knife is distinctiv in three manners: straight lined handle, comb and four tools at one end and just one on the other. Together very unusual!
But just a slight hint to consider. The Nixdorf Comp. Ignaz Rösler Söhne used the term „Feinstahl“ meaning next to „Acier (Super)fine.


And they had many registered brands. The name Rather & Co. sounds British

I think that’s it, a dealers trademark.

It was a marketing ploy.

Probably, as US Companies were always best at marketing.

Abu
 
... the first find:
Germania Cutlery Works. This brand was created by Nathan Kastor in 1896 and existed until his death in 1938. ... "GERMANIA CUTL WORKS" was the name of the Kastors' German plant."
I know that such historical information is showing up on Kastor cutler in some publications but please allow me to correct some misunderstanding which possibly were caused by faults in translating German information.
Nathan Kastor founded his cutlery business in Solingen in 1892, 'Germania Cutlery Works' was just one of dosend brands (brandnames and trademarks of his business) but never was his cutlery business‘s (firm's) name. The correct business name of Nathan Kastor's firm was Kastor & Co. Stahlwarenfabrik.

Kastor 1929.JPG

SG Ind Bez 1921.x.JPG



More about the famous Kastor family ...
Great information on Kastor family's international business both on the German root and the US devision.
An avid US knife collector contributed two outstanding articles in the US cutlery magazine 'KNIFE WORLD':
"Adolpf Kastor & Brothers" Vol. 35 No. 3, March 2009
"The Kastor Family of Tang Stamps" Vol. 37 No.3, March 2011

A listing of blade markings used by KASTOR and that cutler's / importer's different companies is showing up a grandtotal of 347 brandnames or trademarks. Not all are bing confirmed ... but RATHER & C. is not showing up.

The second knife from Rather & Co is a big mystery for all knife lovers.

That is correct ... and I doubt that there is any relationship by KASTOR and RATHER & Co.

I know from a request for identification of your pocket knife's markings from a French colletor, dating back some years. No serious hisory was showig up that time.

regards
cut
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
I know that such historical information is showing up on Kastor cutler in some publications but please allow me to correct some misunderstanding which posibly were caused by faults in translating German information.
Nathan Kastor founded his cutlery business in Solingen in 1892, 'Germania Cutlery Works' was just one of dosend brands (brandnames and trademarks of his business) but never was his cutlery busines (firm's) name. The correct business name of Nathan Kastor's firm was Kastor & Co. Stahlwarenfabrik.

Anhang anzeigen 322864
Anhang anzeigen 322865



Great information on Kastor family's international business both on the German root and the US devision.
An avid US knife collector contributed two outstanding articles in the US cutlery magazine 'KNIFE WORLD':
"Adolpf Kastor & Brothers" Vol. 35 No. 3, March 2009
"The Kastor Family of Tang Stamps" Vol. 37 No.3, March 2011

A listing of blade markings used by KASTOR and that cutler's / importer's different companies is showing up a grandtotal of 347 brandnames or trademarks. Not all are bing confirmed ... but RATHER & C. is not showing up.



That is correct ... and I doubt that there is any relationship by KASTOR and RATHER & Co.

I know from a request for identification of your pocket knife's markings from a French colletor, dating back some years. No serious hisory was showig up that time.

regards
cut
Hello, dear Сut,
and thank you for your encyclopedic knowledge and your time. Like a true sage, you pause, listen to other people's opinions, and only then deliver your correct verdict. We've had another misunderstanding due to the translation. When I wrote my comment on my post, I relied on data from Goins's reference book, which states that the specific Germania Cutlery Works brand was founded and managed by Nathan Kastor in 1896. The parent company, the concern, was founded directly by Adolf Kastor and was called Adolf Kastor & Brothers.

I'm glad you confirmed that Rather & Co was not one of Kastor's brands. Before you, our friend and Bohemian expert Abu also confirmed that this is not a Bohemian knife. Therefore, the search narrows, and by process of elimination, we conclude that it is either a British or French brand, and we should look there.

Thank you, dear friends, for your knowledge and your time.

Sincerely, Arie
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
  • Like
Reaktionen: Abu
Zurück